综艺无双 » 一虎一席谈 » 0719.中小学生该不该读.三国演义-BBsee

[一虎一席谈] 0719.中小学生该不该读.三国演义-BBsee

Description: 「凤凰卫视自1月1日起，每周六20:00-21:00。主持：胡一虎」 @ 2008-07-21 21:00

王泽钊特级语文教师，曾执教于青岛二中等重点中学。最神奇的是，23次“护送”学生闯关高考，多次命中高考作文题，其中还有6名学生在高考中写出过满分作文。最夸张的是，执教授课时弃传统语文教材不用，转而使用自己编写的一套语文教材！现在再度让王泽钊陷入争议的，是他最近发表的一篇《不要再让中小学生读< 三国演义>了》的文章。在该文中，王泽钊鲜明地甩出了自己的观点———“《三国演义》思想性无可称道”，“残暴的皇权，腐朽的忠孝节义，煞费苦心的阴谋诡计，伏尸百万流血漂橹的战场……这些何足称道！”此外，王泽钊还表示《三国演义》也根本算不上文学大作，“首先，它是数代人‘集体创作’ 的产品……陋巷中顽劣小儿喜欢听的故事，是什么品质。其次，在文学想像方面乏善可陈。再次，所塑造的人物公式化：好则好到家，坏则坏到底。诸葛亮就是一个出乎情理之外的人———哪里是人，已几近妖怪……我们要学生从中受到哪些熏陶、哪些滋养？是皇权，是愚忠，是阴谋，抑或是血腥？还是其低俗的写作手法？《三国演义》作为“中小学生必读书”，可以休矣！”

“《三国演义》根本就算不上文学，思想性上也无可称道！”近日，传说中的“语文狂人”王泽钊撰文质疑《三国演义》的名著地位，他公开表示不希望学生读《三国演义》，“《三国演义》被荒谬地列为‘四大名著’之首，实在令人费解……它对学生没有任何帮助，不应该把它作为中小学生必读书。”王泽钊的言论更被一网站归纳做成了“呼吁把《三国演义》踢出四大名著”的讨论主题

25 条留言

1 Abdellatif Commented @ 20:37:26 on 2014-06-09
This is a most useful cortiibutnon to the debate
2 cialis online pharmacy Commented @ 20:36:13 on 2014-06-11
IJWTS wow! Why can’t I think of things like that?
3 medical preferences Commented @ 11:50:40 on 2014-06-29
Such an impressive answer! You’ve beaten us all with that!
4 raises rates Commented @ 02:39:47 on 2014-07-09
I have exactly what info I want. Check, please. Wait, it’s free? Awesome!
5 out-of-control Commented @ 00:29:59 on 2014-07-10
Thinking like that is really impressive
6 like standard Commented @ 16:41:06 on 2014-07-22
That’s a shrewd answer to a tricky question
7 florida car insurance quote Commented @ 15:47:23 on 2014-07-26
Gee willikers, that’s such a great post!
8 changes increased Commented @ 09:46:32 on 2014-08-02
IMHO you’ve got the right answer!
9 getting hard Commented @ 23:50:41 on 2014-08-09
God, I feel like I should be takin notes! Great work
10 erectile Commented @ 17:34:51 on 2014-08-18
My problem was a wall until I read this, then I smashed it.
11 purchase viagra Commented @ 07:48:58 on 2014-08-23
That hits the target perfectly. Thanks!
12 yithoy Commented @ 20:05:16 on 2014-09-14
ttzyaycq
13 hello Commented @ 03:10:20 on 2014-09-19
fspmhpi hfsgptag
14 some remaining Commented @ 23:14:16 on 2014-10-10
Thanky Thanky for all this good information!
15 payday loans Commented @ 19:26:50 on 2014-10-31
wqatsi payday loans
16 instant health insurance Commented @ 00:55:45 on 2014-11-11
Articles like this are an example of quick, helpful answers.
17 mobile loans Commented @ 23:28:19 on 2014-11-17
yioabkzl mobile loans
18 payday loans Commented @ 03:33:04 on 2014-11-22
dvybthv payday loans
19 mobile loans Commented @ 04:17:11 on 2014-12-02
fcmfcb mobile loans
20 no credit check payday loans Commented @ 07:45:16 on 2014-12-17
zoupuq no credit check payday loans
21 payday loan Commented @ 01:56:06 on 2014-12-29
auzzyi payday loan
22 fececlbi Commented @ 12:23:01 on 2015-01-26
qigcuw
23 hello Commented @ 19:18:11 on 2015-02-04
chgrowfo wmvyoie
24 buy cialis online Commented @ 16:31:40 on 2015-02-17
I really appreciate free, succinct, reliable data like this.
25 buy cialis 25mg online Commented @ 21:28:56 on 2015-02-18
Keep on writing and chugging away!